Thanks to all y'all for your great response to yesterday's post on banned books. I did, however, make an error or, as those of of us who grew up Catholic would call it, a sin of omission by not including the link to the American Library Association's excellent Banned Books site. I wish all sins could be so easily corrected. There lots more books that have been challenged listed there -- some will astound and puzzle you -- others will raise your blood pressure. The Harry Potter series is a prime example. In addition to being an interesting and fun read, they got a lot of kids reading who may not have done so otherwise. I read them and liked them and so do my children and grandchildren. And the English teacher in my soul says that anything that catches a child's imagination and gets them reading is a good thing. It's fantasy and anyone who thinks most kids don't understand that is plain damned sick.
In a twisted way, I like the would-be book burners because if I see that a book is being banned, it sends me out to the bookstore to buy a copy. I have to find out what all the shouting is about. As a result, I met some outstanding authors who I otherwise may have missed and I'm guessing, from your responses here, that I'm not alone and in very good company! Thanks!!!!!
Happy Blogging and Happy Reading!!!!!!
Kay
Interesting, Kay. I avoid fantasy because I find the boredom factor high. To each her own!
ReplyDeleteCop Car
Kay: thanks for the good words for Harry Potter! Like Cop Car, I tend to be allergic to fantasy. But Harry Potter grabbed me from the beginning of the first book and never let go. I loved it for the human story it was.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Xtreme English about Harry Potter and I can't believe there are people who would keep a child from reading those books. They are and will always be treasures.
ReplyDeleteI AGREE!!!!!! Potter on!
ReplyDeleteGood on ya Gal!!!!
John
we are travelling, but I could not miss a chance to read and comment. Sins of Omission - wow, I hadn't thought about that for a long time. Do you also remember the League of Decency and the Sunday morning pledge to avoid certain movies as well as books.
ReplyDeleteLike you, it only made me waht to read those books all the more. I got into deep trouble in High School for doing a book report on Lady Chatterly's Lover. The nuns were more than unhappy, but fortunately, my older brother stuck up for me at home and my parents kind of came around to my side.
we are travelling, but I could not miss a chance to read and comment. Sins of Omission - wow, I hadn't thought about that for a long time. Do you also remember the League of Decency and the Sunday morning pledge to avoid certain movies as well as books.
ReplyDeleteLike you, it only made me waht to read those books all the more. I got into deep trouble in High School for doing a book report on Lady Chatterly's Lover. The nuns were more than unhappy, but fortunately, my older brother stuck up for me at home and my parents kind of came around to my side.
I think this old motto sums up my wish for book banners and burners: .Evil to him who thinks evil
ReplyDeleteFunny ... I read the first Harry Potter book, which I thought was just "okay" and I saw the movie, which I found kind of boring. I just didn't get it. But I nevertheless applaud Rowling and her series b/c I agree wholeheartedly: "anything that catches a child's imagination and gets them reading is a good thing."
ReplyDeleteI always got a laugh out of the book-banners who claimed that the Harry Potter series was anti-Christian.
ReplyDeleteHogwarts and the students celebrated Christmas!
I think it would be fun to write a banned book.
ReplyDeleteWhy would anyone keep children from reading these books? I rarely get to read much these days, but I have read some fantasy books..and enjoyed them very much. Maybe it's just me...I don't think I've ever really grown up. I do like Harry Potter...
ReplyDeleteI have to confess that even as a kid, I never cared for fantasy. I guess my mind just doesn't work that way; realism - biographies and the like - appealed to me, even in 4th and 5th grade. However, I know many, many adults who've eagerly read every Potter book and have been enthralled with them.
ReplyDeleteI can't imagine banning it or any other book. What puzzles me is that so many of the people who want certain books banned often admit out loud that they haven't even read the boo!!!
Kay, it's been a long time since I heard "sins of omission"...but Catholics do have a long memory.
ReplyDeleteWe banned Barbie books for a while, but Barbie is EVERYWHERE, and reading is reading and values are values. We'll just ho
pe for the best outcome.